?

Log in

 
 
19 October 2010 @ 02:04 pm
What Do You Guys Think?  

There are a few characters I'm on the fence with, regarding if they should be included on here. I need some input.
 
Poll #1633052 Should They Count? (ticking the box means 'yes')

Are They 'Young' Heroes?

BoomBoom (Tabitha Smith)
3(18.8%)
Chamber (Jonothon Starsmore)
4(25.0%)
Cipher (Alisa Tager)
4(25.0%)
Jubilee (Jubilation Lee)
5(31.2%)

Are They Heroes?

Alex Wilder
1(25.0%)
Quentin Quire
0(0.0%)
Esme Cuckoo
3(75.0%)

Also, regarding the New Warriors, should the team/series count as an X-title or go under 'miscellaneous'?
Poll #1633053 re; New Warriors

NW(II) - miscellaneous or X-title?

it's an X-Men spin-off
1(20.0%)
it should be under 'miscellaneous'
4(80.0%)
 
Please feel free to explain your choice(s) by commenting here, if you like. 
 
.
 
 
Current Mood: aggravatedaggravated
 
 
 
The Mad Fan Girlfullmetal_cute on October 19th, 2010 06:31 pm (UTC)
I'd say any character created from the mid-90s onward could qualify as a young hero (though the call is ultimately yours). As for Quentin and Alex, I'm on the fence about them: on the one hand, what both of them had done is undeniably evil, but on the other hand, it was done for the best of intentions.

Also, minor itty bitty quibble, the New Warriors group you're referring to is technically the 4th incarnation of the team.
Pixie Child: marvel; New X-Men IIv13 - Dani&Xi'anfai_dust on October 19th, 2010 09:37 pm (UTC)
"I'd say any character created from the mid-90s onward could qualify as a young hero."
That sounds like a good over-all rule.

"As for Quentin and Alex, I'm on the fence about them: on the one hand, what both of them had done is undeniably evil, but on the other hand, it was done for the best of intentions."
See, at first, I was thinking 'no way in hell', but Quentin is a good guy in a few alternate universes even though he's not in 616; which lead me to wonder 'if I count Quentin, shouldn't I also include Alex?'. It's a stumper.

"Also, minor itty bitty quibble, the New Warriors group you're referring to is technically the 4th incarnation of the team."
It's not itty-bitty. Thanks!
The Mad Fan Girlfullmetal_cute on October 19th, 2010 09:43 pm (UTC)
Maybe expand the list to include Anti-heroes and villains?

Also, got another book with some young heroes that you may wanna check up on: Young Allies. And sooner or later, I will get those Avengers Academy and Avengers: the Initiative images to you. *headdesk*
Pixie Child: marvel; Target Xfai_dust on October 20th, 2010 12:37 am (UTC)
Yeah, maybe. *sigh* That shouldn't be as overwealming as it is, except I spent the day on comicvine making the second masterlist for here, for titles/concepts/locations/alt. universes. Which was only supposed to be titles & universes, but it got out of hand.
The Mad Fan Girlfullmetal_cute on October 20th, 2010 01:03 am (UTC)
Nature of the beast, ESPECIALLY if you want to be thorough.
Pixie Child: marvel; New X-Men IIv13 - Dani&Xi'anfai_dust on October 20th, 2010 01:34 am (UTC)
And I do. It was the whole point of this, yeah? *grin* Serously, though, 9 and a half hours? That's more then a workday.
The Mad Fan Girlfullmetal_cute on October 20th, 2010 01:38 am (UTC)
The things we do for love.
Pixie Child: marvel; UncannyXMen v500 - Pixiefai_dust on October 20th, 2010 01:41 am (UTC)
Yup. Love, obsession.... whatever you want to call it. ^_^